The French consumer rights organization Halte a l’Obsolescence Programmee (HOP) has successfully pushed for a legal case against Apple. Following a multi-year investigation, French prosecutors have referred the company to the Paris Criminal Court over allegations of planned obsolescence and restrictions on device repairs.

The legal dispute originated from a complaint filed by HOP in December 2022, which led to a formal investigation in May 2023. The organization alleges that Apple uses software and hardware mechanisms to limit third-party repairs. Specifically, Apple links components to device serial numbers, which can cause functional issues if parts are replaced by unauthorized service providers.

HOP claims that even when original official parts are used, devices may still malfunction or face restricted functionality after repairs. This practice is considered illegal under the French Consumer Code as amended in 2021. Apple maintains that its serialization mechanism is designed to ensure component compatibility, safety, and user experience.

To address repair concerns, Apple launched a self-service repair program in France on December 6, 2022, allowing users to purchase official parts and tools. The Paris Criminal Court has scheduled the first hearing for this case for February 25, 2027, where the court will examine Apple's repair policies and the impact of its serialization practices.