S&P Global Ratings has introduced its Vault Risk Assessment (VRA) framework, which evaluates DeFi lending products by focusing on human and operational factors rather than just smart contract code. The framework, launched in October 2026, assesses risks across six categories, including governance, operational security, and curator risk.

According to S&P research published on November 17, 2026, the majority of hacking losses over the past five years stem from failures in operational risk management, governance weaknesses, and access control issues. Annual losses related to these vulnerabilities range from 0.07% to 0.30% of on-chain asset value, which the agency deems to exceed acceptable levels for critical financial infrastructure.

The scale of the sector has grown significantly, with deposits in digital-asset lending vaults rising from $1,5 billion in September 2024 to approximately $10 billion by September 2026. Recent market volatility in March and April 2026 resulted in cumulative losses of approximately $600 million across various DeFi platforms.

Analyst Andrew O’Neill emphasizes that transparency on the blockchain does not mitigate risks associated with human control over admin keys or governance decisions. The VRA framework reflects S&P’s broader expansion into digital asset coverage, applying traditional credit analysis methods to evaluate the management and operational structures of on-chain protocols.