The French consumer rights organization Halte à l'Obsolescence Programmée (HOP) initiated legal action against Apple regarding its repair practices. The case centers on the company's parts pairing mechanism, which links components like screens, batteries, and cameras to specific devices.
HOP alleges that this system restricts independent repair shops and causes functional issues when users replace parts outside of official channels, even if original components are used. The complaint covers 24 iPhone models and repair practices conducted between November 2021 and July 2024.
While the organization characterizes the issue as planned obsolescence, the formal charges under French consumer law involve the obstruction of repair and refurbishment. Apple has denied the allegations, stating they are baseless and emphasizing that the mechanism is intended to protect user privacy and device security.
Apple noted that it has already removed some restrictions, such as enabling True Tone functionality after third-party screen replacements. The company also expanded support for used original parts, initially available for the iPhone 15 and newer models.
A procedural hearing for the case is scheduled for February 25, 2027, with the main court proceedings expected to take place in June 2027. HOP acknowledged the adjustments made by Apple but maintains that the practical impact of these changes remains to be seen.





